Hawaii Ocean Time-series (HOT)
in the School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology at the University of Hawai'i at Manoa


IES Recovery Cruise: Chief Scientist Report


Chief Scientist: F. SANTIAGO-MANDUJANO


IES Recovery Cruise Report
November 26, 1999

By F. Santiago-Mandujano and M. Valenciano

IES Recovery Cruise
Vessel:  R/V Ka'imikai O Kanaloa, University of Hawaii
Master of the Vessel: Captain Robert Hayes
Chief Scientist: Fernando Santiago-Mandujano

Cruise Planning

Plans to recover the bottom moored Inverted Echo Sounder from the center of the 
ALOHA circle were started after the UH Marine Center (S. Winslow) and Captain R. 
Hayes agreed to transfer the cable from the R/V Moana Wave's winch into the R/V 
Ka'Imikai-O-Kanaloa's (KOK) trawling winch.  The original cable on the KOK's 
winch was too short to conduct this type of operation. The transfer took place 
during the first week of November. M. Valenciano was present for a short period 
during unspooling of the KOK's cable by D. Gravatt and Capt. Hayes. We do not 
have any details of how the cable transfer was conducted (see addendum below).

Discussions with R. Lukas, Capt. Hayes, H. Ramm, L. Tupas, D. Hebel and S. 
Poulos were conducted to plan the recovery strategies for the cruise.  R. Lukas 
suggested the use of grappling hooks on the wire. Drawings and sketches from the 
previous IES recovery attempt were obtained from H. Ramm. H. Ramm also commented 
that during that attempt apparently there was not enough cable payed out. The 
Captain of the R/V Moana Wave (J. Stahl) apparently did not want to risk paying 
out additional cable due to an upcomming cruise which would require use of the 
cable. L. Tupas agreed to lend us the grappling hooks that they had borrowed 
from AT&T. We decided not to use these hooks given that they are too massive and 
we did not want to risk loosing them.

Capt. Hayes suggested to circle the IES with one weight, without grappling 
hooks, paying out all the cable (12,000 m out of the 12,600 m on the drum), and 
dragging until the anchor weight was sensed on the load cell. Then the cable 
would be retrieved just until the weight was off the ocean floor. If the IES did 
not surface the ship would reposition and another attempt would be made.

A cruise plan was drafted where the first portion was based on Capt. Hayes' 
suggestions. Two additional techniques were added as alternative procedures to 
try (see attached cruise plan). The second technique, consisting of a second 
weight attached around the cable and allowed to free fall to the bottom, was 
added to the plan after consultation and approval from Capt. Hayes. The cruise 
plan was reviewed and commented by C. Nosse and R. Lukas, and submitted to the 
Marine Center and Capt. Hayes on November 19. Capt. Hayes commented that the 
operations would depend on the conditions at station ALOHA.

Cruise preparations, November 18

M. Valenciano secured some old anchor chain laying around at Snug.  Permission 
to use it was obtained from S. Winslow.  Alton Goo, at the machine shop, allowed 
the use of an  Ox-Acetylene torch to cut the chain.  The chain was cut into 700 
and 1200 pound (estimates) lengths.  The chain was then staged near the pier for 
loading  
 
Cruise loading, November 19

M. Valenciano loaded all necessary cruise supplies on board the R/V KOK, he also 
requested to Capt. Hayes that the staged anchor chain be loaded on the ship.

An old cut CTD wire was also loaded to be used with cable clamps to bind the 
large chain together necessary for the second recovery procedure. The use of 
this cable would save extra expenses (about $60) for additional chain. Later, 
prior to the cruise departure Capt. Hayes provided some chain which could fit 
into the links of the large chain.

Cruise departure, November 21

Prior to cruise departure, Capt. Hayes stated that he would deploy the cable in 
a "U" shaped pattern instead of the circle shape planned, with the justification 
that there would be more cable on the ground.

The ship departed from Snug Harbor at 0900 (HST) with the following  
participants:

F. Santiago-Mandujano (chief scientist)
C. Nosse
D. Wright
M. Valenciano
J. Johnson (volunteer)

W. Hervig (STAG)
D. Gravatt (STAG)
Cruise Operations

Arrived to the IES location on November 21 at 2000. Prior to arrival M. 
Valenciano asked the Captain if it was possible for the Science party to have 
access to the readings of wire tension and amount of wire payed out. The Captain 
indicated that it was not necessary for the Science party to be involved in any 
of the operations as he would handle them. The Science party proceeded to 
monitor the operations from the Rock Lab via the closed circuit TV monitor, the 
VHF radio , and the "Clear Com" intercom system.

2100: (22 44.2N, 158 1.6W). A 2000 lb. lead weight was deployed at 65 m/min, 
paying out 1500 m of cable.

2130: The 1200 lb. anchor chain was attached to the cable via a stopper block 
assembly (rigged by D. Gravatt) at 1500 m. (Note, this procedure was not part of 
the cruise plan).

2137: (22 44.9N, 158 0.9W). Chain being deployed. Tension on the wire 3,800 lb.

2147: After 2,200 m of cable have been payed out the winch stopped because the 
cable was being buried into the lower layers of cable on the drum.

2219: (22 45N, 158 0.3W). Apparently the problem could not be solved and the 
cable started to slip and at this point the Captain decided to cut the cable. C. 
Nosse recalls hearing that there were 16,000 pounds of tension on the wire; 
however, it is not clear as to what may have caused this. The cable was cut 
releasing the 2,200 m of cable and the two weights. Upon hearing that the cable 
may be cut, the Science Party attempted, unsuccessfully, to contact the Bridge 
to request that they cut the cable outside the ALOHA circle.

The Captain indicated that it would not be possible to fix the winch and cable 
situation to continue operations; therefore, it was decided to terminate all 
operations and return to Honolulu. F Santiago-Mandujano contacted R. Lukas by 
cell phone to communicate him about the problems with the operations.

Post-cruise discussion with Capt. Hayes indicated the following:

1) The wire slipped off the first sheave from the winch drum while under load.  
(See Figure 1)
2) The winch manufacturer is out of business.  No parts are available.
3) Level winding not working.
4) Incorrect shell size.  The shell is a molded form, custom made for each cable 
size, which is fitted to the winch drum prior to winding the first layer of 
cable.  It's function is to distribute the load and provide proper spacing of 
the cable.  It is not clear if the incorrect shell is installed on the winch or 
if the wire was wound on the winch without a shell.  There are two shell halves 
stowed under the winch drum.
5) Cable was cut because the wire was slipping.
6) Future recovery operations not possible due to insufficient wire on the 
winch.

Apparently some of the reasons why the cable buried into the cable layers was 
because the cable was not spooled under tension, as indicated by the loose 
windings seen in the drum (See Figure 2). However as indicated before, we do not 
have any details of how the cable spooling was conducted (see addendum below).

Arrived to Snug Harbor on November 22 at 0800. Equipment was unloaded at 1200.

Only ADCP data were obtained during the cruise. The pumping system of the 
continuous water supply was being repaired therefore thermosalinograph data were 
not available.

It is not clear as to why the wire was cut.  We have not received a formal 
written explanation from the Captain, nor from the Marine Center, stating what 
actually ocurred (see addendum below).

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Addendum, 1/24/2000

Captain James W. Coste, Marine Superintendent.

"In 1995, due to past problems that we've had with this particular winch, we
completely modified the fairlead arrangement. At that time, it was set up to 
spool 0.972 inch fiber optic cable. This fact was either forgotten or
overlooked by Marine Center personnel. In other words, 9/16-inch wire was
spooled on the drum using a fairlead designed to accommodate one-inch wire.
As a result, the wire was spooled on in a loose, random fashion.

When the wire was paid out and as the drag increased, the wire buried itself
and jammed so that it could neither be paid our nor recovered. Captain Hayes 
had little option other than to cut the cable at the drum. When funds
become available, we will modify the winch to allow us to change the
gearing system so that it will also accommodate 9/16-inch wire. The
modification will take 4-5 weeks. It is still inoperative.