Introduction
|
1. Oceanic Time-series Measurements
| |
Systematic, long-term time-series studies of selected aquatic and
terrestrial habitats have yielded significant contributions to earth
and ocean sciences through the characterization of climate trends.
Important examples include the recognition of acid rain (Hubbard Brook
long-term ecological study, Vermont; Likens et al., 1977), the
documentation of increasing carbon dioxide (CO2) in the
earth's atmosphere (Mauna Loa Observatory, Hawaii; Keeling et al.,
1976) and the description of large scale ocean-atmosphere climate
interactions in the equatorial Pacific Ocean (Southern Oscillation
index; Troup, 1965).
Long time-series observations of climate-relevant variables in the
ocean are extremely important, yet they are rare. Repeated
oceanographic measurements are required to gain an understanding of
natural processes or phenomena that exhibit slow or irregular change,
as well as rapid event-driven variations that are impossible to
document reliably from a single field expedition. Time-series studies
are also ideally suited for the documentation of complex natural
phenomena that are under the combined influence of physical, chemical
and biological controls. Examination of data derived from the few
long-term oceanic time-series that do exist provides ample incentive
and scientific justification to establish additional study sites (Wiebe
et al., 1987).
The role of the oceans in climate variability is primarily in the
sequestration and transportation of heat and carbon (Barnett, 1978).
Both can be introduced into the ocean in one place, only to return to
the atmosphere, at a subsequent time, possibly at a distant location.
While both heat and carbon can be exchanged with the atmosphere only
carbon is lost to the seafloor through sedimentation. The oceans are
known to play a central role in regulating the global concentration Of
CO2 in the atmosphere (Sarmiento and Toggweiler, 1984;
Dymond and Lyle, 1985). It is generally believed that the world ocean
has removed a significant portion of anthropogenic CO2 added
to the atmosphere, although the precise partitioning between the ocean
and terrestrial spheres is not well constrained (Tans et al., 1990;
Quay et al., 1992; Keeling and Shertz, 1992).
The cycling of carbon within the ocean is controlled by a set of
reversible, reduction-oxidation reactions involving dissolved
inorganic carbon (DIC) and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) with marine
biota serving as the critical catalysts. Detailed information on the
rates and mechanisms of removal of DIC from the surface ocean by
biological processes, the export of biogenic carbon (both as organic
and carbonate particles) to the ocean's interior, and the sites of
remineralization and burial are all of considerable importance in the
carbon cycle. The continuous downward flux of biogenic materials,
termed the "biological pump" (Volk and Hoffert, 1985; Longhurst and
Harrison, 1989), is a central component of all contemporary studies of
biogeochemical cycling in the ocean and, therefore, of all studies of
global environmental change.
During the embryonic phase of ocean exploration more than a century ago
(Thomson, 1877), it was realized that a comprehensive understanding of
the oceanic habitat and its biota would require a multidisciplinary
experimental approach and extensive field observations. Progress
toward this goal has been limited by natural habitat variability, both
in space and time, and by logistical constraints of ship-based
sampling. Consequently, our current view of many complex oceanographic
processes is likely biased (e.g., Dickey, 1991; Wiggert et al., 1994).
The synoptic and repeat perspective that is now available from research
satellites is expected to improve our understanding of oceanic
variability, despite certain limitations.
In 1988, two deep ocean time-series hydrostations were established with
support from the U.S. National Science
Foundation (NSF): one in the western North Atlantic Ocean near the
historical Panulirus Station (Bermuda Atlantic Time-series
Study [BATS]; Michaels and Knap, 1996) and the other in the
subtropical North Pacific Ocean near Hawaii (Hawaii Ocean Time-series
[HOT]; Karl and Lukas, 1996). These programs were established and are
currently operated by scientists at Bermuda Biological Station for
Research and the University of Hawaii, respectively.
The primary research objectives of these ocean measurement programs are
to establish and maintain deep-water hydrostations for observing and
interpreting physical and biogeochemical variability. The initial
design called for repeat measurements of a suite of core parameters at
approximately monthly intervals, compilation of the data and rapid
distribution to the scientific community.
| |
2. HOT Station ALOHA: Roots and Branches
| |
A deep-ocean weather station network was established in the post-World
War II period as a ship-based observation program designed to improve
global weather prediction capabilities. One of the sites, Station
November, was located in the eastern sector of the North Pacific Ocean
gyre at 30N, 140W and was occupied during 121 cruises between July
1966 and May 1974. The intercruise frequency ranged from a few days to
a few weeks with a typical cruise duration of 2-3 weeks, including
transits. Water samples were collected from approximately 12-14 depths
in the range of 0-1500m using bottles equipped with deep-sea reversing
thermometers. Salinity and, on occasion, dissolved oxygen
concentrations were measured from the discrete water samples.
During the 1970s, most of the U.S. weather ship stations were phased
out of operation and were eventually replaced with more cost-effective,
unattended ocean buoys. These buoys measure standard meteorological
parameters as well as basic wave characteristics (e.g., significant
wave direction, height, period and spectrum) but few, if any,
hydrographic variables.
Physical and biogeochemical time-series investigations of the North
Pacific subtropical region are sparse and consist of a series of
unrelated research programs including CliMAX, GOLLUM, NORPAX, VERTEX,
ADIOS and most recently HOT. CliMAX I
occupied a series of stations near 28N, 155W during August-September
1968 and CliMAX II reoccupied the site during September of the
following year. Since that time, scientists from the Scripps
Institution of 0ceanography have revisited the "CliMAX region" (26.5 to
31N, 150.5 to 158W) on 18 cruises between 1971 and 1985 (Hayward,
1987). It is important to emphasize that the temporal coverage in this
time-series is biased with respect to season because approximately 70%
of the cruises occurred in summer (June-Sept) and 35% were in August
alone. These observations are also aliased by the annual cycle because
no cruises were conducted in 1970, 1975, 1978-79, 1981 or 1984.
Nevertheless, observations made during this extensive series of
cruises, especially the measurements of plankton distributions,
nutrient concentrations and rates of primary production, provided an
unprecedented view of the oligotrophic North Pacific ecosystem
structure and dynamics.
From January 1969 to June 1970, a deep ocean hydrostation
(Station GOLLUM) was established by
scientists at the University of Hawaii at a location 47 km north of
Oahu (22 10'N, 158 00'W; Gordon, 1970). The water depth was 4760m
and the location was selected to be beyond the biogeochemical
influences of the Hawaiian Ridge (Doty and Oguri, 1956). On
approximately monthly intervals, 13 two-day research cruises were
conducted to observe and interpret variations in particulate organic
matter distributions in the water column and other parameters (Gordon,
1970).
A major advance in our understanding of biogeochemical processes in the
sea was made during the NSF International Decade for Ocean Exploration
(IDOE)-sponsored Geochemical Ocean Sections Study (GEOSECS) Pacific Ocean expedition (August 1973 -
June 1974). Although repeated ocean observations were not made during
GEOSECS, the high-precision data, including numerous radioactive and
stable isotopic tracers, that were collected from selected stations in
the central North Pacific Ocean can be used as the basis for assessing
"change," especially for the concentration and 13C isotopic
composition of the total dissolved carbon dioxide pool (Quay et al.,
1992). In particular, GEOSECS stations #202 (33 6'N, 139 34'W), #204
(31 22'N, 150 2'W), #212 (30N, 159 50'W) and #235 (16'45'N,
161'19'W) are the most relevant to our current biogeochemical
investigations at Station ALOHA.
In the early 1970's the North Pacific experiment (NORPAX) was initiated
as an additional component of the NSF-IDOE. Research was focused on
large scale interactions between the ocean and the atmosphere (e.g., El
Niño), and the application of this knowledge to long-range climate
forecasting. The Anomaly Dynamics Study was one component of NORPAX
aimed at understanding interannual variability of the mid-latitude,
North Pacific upper ocean thermal structure. Long-term ocean
observation programs were fundamental to the success of NORPAX and,
accordingly, the Trans-Pac XBT program and the Pacific Sea Level
Network were established. Furthermore, the extensive 15 cruise
Hawaii-to-Tahiti Shuttle time-series experiment (January 1979 - June
1980) was conducted to obtain direct measurements of the temporal
variations in thermal structure of the equatorial Pacific region.
These cruises also supported extensive ancillary research programs on
chemical and biological oceanography, and provided a rich dataset
including measurements of DIC and primary productivity (Wyrtki et al.,
1981).
With the abandonment of the central North Pacific Ocean weather ship
stations and time-series programs such as Station GOLLUM, there
remained very few sites where comprehensive serial measurements of the
internal variability of the ocean were continuing. The
Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC) and World Climate
Research Program (WCRP) Committee on Climate Change in the Ocean (CCCO)
recognized this deficiency, and in 1981 endorsed the initiation of new
ocean observation programs. Reactivation of Station GOLLUM was an
explicit recommendation (JSC/CCCO, 1981).
In 1986, a biogeochemical time-series station was established in the
northeast Pacific Ocean (33'N, 139'W) as one component of the
NSF-sponsored Vertical Transport and Exchange (VERTEX) research program. A major objective of
the VERTEX time-series project was to investigate seasonality in carbon
export from the euphotic zone in relation to contemporaneous primary
production. During an 18-month period (October 1986 - May 1988), the
station was occupied for seven 1 -week periods on approximately 3-month
intervals. In addition to standard hydrographic surveys, samples were
also collected for the measurement of dissolved inorganic and organic
nutrients, particulate matter elemental analysis, primary production,
nitrogen assimilation rates, microbial biomass and particle flux
(Knauer et al., 1990; Harrison et al., 1992). Significant variability
was observed in rates of primary production and particle flux and no
clear relationship was found between new production and primary
production. Despite the comprehensive scope and intensity of this
research project, the sampling frequency was clearly inadequate to
resolve much of the natural variability in this oligotrophic oceanic
ecosystem.
In response to the growing awareness of the ocean's role in climate and
global environmental change, and the need for additional and more
comprehensive oceanic time-series measurements, the Board on Ocean
Science and Policy (BOSP) of the National Research Council (NRC)
sponsored a workshop on "Global Observations and Understanding of the
General Circulation of the Oceans" in August 1983. The proceedings of
this workshop (National Research Council, 1984a) served as a prospectus
for the development of the U.S. component of the World Ocean
Circulation Experiment (U.S.-WOCE). U.S.-WOCE has the following
objectives: (1) to understand the general circulation of the global
ocean, to model with confidence its present state and predict its
evolution in relation to long-term changes in the atmosphere and (2) to
provide the scientific background for designing an observation system
for long-term measurement of the large-scale circulation of the ocean.
In a parallel effort, a separate research program termed Global Ocean Flux Study
(GOFS) focused on the ocean's carbon cycle and associated air-sea
fluxes of carbon dioxide. In September 1984, NRC-BOSP sponsored a
workshop on "Global Ocean Flux Study" which served as an eventual
blueprint for the GOFS program (National Research Council, 1984b). In
1986, the International Council of Scientific Unions (ICSU) established
the International Geosphere-Biosphere Programme: A Study of Global
Change (IGBP), and the following year JGOFS (Joint GOFS) was designed
as a Core Project of IGBP. U.S.-JGOFS research efforts focus on the
oceanic carbon cycle, its sensitivity to change and the regulation of
the atmosphere-ocean CO2 balance (Brewer et al., 1986).
The broad objectives of U.S.-JGOFS are: (1) to determine and understand
on a global scale the time-varying fluxes of carbon and associated
biogenic elements in the ocean and (2) to evaluate the related
exchanges of these elements with the atmosphere, the sea floor and the
continental boundaries (SCOR, 1990, JGOFS Rept. #5). To achieve these
goals, four separate program elements were defined: (1) process studies
to capture key regular events, (2) long-term time-series observations
at strategic sites, (3) a global survey of relevant oceanic properties
(e.g., CO2) and (4) a vigorous data interpretation and
modeling effort to disseminate knowledge and to generate testable
hypotheses.
In 1987, two separate proposals were submitted to the U.S.-WOCE and
U.S.-JGOFS program committees to establish a multi-disciplinary, deep
water hydrostation in Hawaiian waters. In July 1988, these proposals
were funded by the National Science Foundation and Station ALOHA was officially on the map.
| |
3. HOT Program Design and Implementation
| |
| |
3.1. P.O. and BEACH objectives for HOT
| |
The primary objective of HOT is to obtain a long time-series of
physical and biochemical observations in the North Pacific subtropical
gyre that will address the goals of the U.S. Global Change Research
Program. The objectives specific to the Physical Oceanography (P.O.)
program are to:
- Document and understand seasonal and interannual variability of
water masses.
- Relate water mass variations to gyre fluctuations.
- Determine the need and methods for monitoring currents at Station ALOHA.
- Develop a climatology of short-term physical variability.
In addition to these general primary objectives, the physical
oceanographic component of HOT provides CTD/rosette sampling support
for the biogeochemistry & ecology (BEACH) time-series sampling program,
and supports development of new instrumentation for hydrographic observations.
The objectives of HOT specific to the BEACH program are to:
- Document and understand seasonal and interannual variability in the
rates of primary production, new production and particle export from
the surface ocean.
- Determine the mechanisms and rates of nutrient input and recycling,
especially for nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) in the upper 200m of the
water column.
- Measure the time-varying concentrations of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC)
in the upper water column and estimate the annual air-to-sea CO2 flux.
In addition to these primary objectives, the HOT Program
provides logistical support for numerous complementary
research programs.
| |
3.2. Initial HOT program design considerations
| |
There are both scientific and logistical considerations involved with
the establishment of any long-term, time-series measurement program.
Foremost among these is site selection, choice of variables to be
measured and general sampling design, including sampling frequency.
Equally important design considerations are those dealing with the
choice of analytical methods for a given candidate variable, especially
an assessment of the desired accuracy and precision, and availability
of suitable reference materials, the hierarchy of sampling replication
and, for data collected at a fixed geographical location, mesoscale
horizontal variability.
The HOT program was initially conceived as being a deep-ocean, ship-
and mooring- based observation experiment that would have an
approximately 20-year lifetime. Consequently, we selected a core suite
of environmental variables that might be expected to display detectable
change on time scales of several days to one decade. Except for the
availability of existing satellite and ocean buoy sea surface data, the
initial phase of the HOT program (Oct 1988 - Feb 1991) was entirely
supported by research vessels. In February 1991, an array of five
inverted echo sounders (IES) was deployed in an approximately 150
km2 network around Station ALOHA (Chiswell, 1996) and in
June 1992, a sequencing sediment trap mooring was deployed a few km
north of Station ALOHA (Karl, 1994). In 1993, the IES network was
replaced with two strategically-positioned instruments: one at Station
ALOHA and the other at Station Kaena. Except for brief service
intervals, both the Station ALOHA IES transducer and ALOHA sediment
trap mooring have been collecting data since their respective initial
deployments.
| |
3.3. Station ALOHA site selection
| |
We evaluated several major criteria prior to selection of the site for
the HOT oligotrophic ocean benchmark hydrostation. First, the station
must be located in deep water (>4000 m), upwind (north-northeast) of
the main Hawaiian islands and of sufficient distance from land to be
free from coastal ocean dynamics and biogeochemical influences. On the
other hand, the station should be close enough to the port of Honolulu
to make relatively short duration (<5 d) monthly cruises logistically
and financially feasible. A desirable, but less stringent criterion
would locate the station at, or near, previously studied regions of the
central North Pacific Ocean, in particular Station GOLLUM.
After consideration of these criteria, we established our primary
sampling site at 22' 45'N, 158' 00'W at a location approximately 100 km
north of the island of Oahu, and generally restrict our monthly
sampling activities to a circle with a 6 nmi radius around this nominal
site. Station ALOHA is in deep water (4750
m) and is more than one Rossby radius (50 km) away from steep
topography associated with the Hawaiian Ridge. We also established a
coastal station W-SW of the island of Oahu, approximately 10 km off
Kahe Point (21' 20.6'N, 158' 16.4'W) in 1500 m of water. Station Kahe serves as a coastal analogue to
our deep-water site and the data collected there provide a near-shore
time-series for comparison to our primary open ocean site. Station
Kahe is also used to test our equipment each month before departing for
Station ALOHA, and to train new personnel at the beginning of each
cruise. From January 1997 to October 2000, a physical-biogeochemical mooring
was deployed to obtain continuous measurements of various atmospheric and
oceanographic parameters. The mooring was located at 22' 28' N, 158' 8' W and
was designated as Station HALE-ALOHA.
In August 2004, HALE-ALOHA was redeployed at a site 6 nautical miles west
of Station ALOHA (22' 46' N, 158' 5.5' W) as part of the Multi-diciplinary Ocean
Sensors for Environmental Analyses and Networks
(MOSEAN) project. MOSEAN is
directed toward new technologies that will lead to increased observations that
are essential for solving a variety of interdisciplinary oceanographic problems.
These include: biogeochemical cycling, climate change effects, ocean pollution,
harmful algal blooms (HABs), ocean ecology and underwater visibility. This site,
also called Station 51, is a collaboration with the University of California Santa
Barbara and WET Labs.
Also in August 2004, a surface mooring outfitted for meteorological and
oceanographic measurements was deployed 6 nautical miles east of Station ALOHA
(22' 46' N, 157' 54' W). Ever since, CTD casts have been taken during various HOT
cruises near the mooring for calibration of the moored instruments. This site,
named WHOTS is a
collaboration with the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. It has also been called
Station 50. It is intended to provide long-term, high-quality air-sea fluxes as a
coordinated part of the HOT program and contribute to the goals of observing heat,
fresh water and chemical fluxes. The approach is to maintain a surface mooring by
successive mooring turnarounds (Plueddemann, et al., 2006).These observations will
be used to investigate air sea interaction processes related to climate variability.
| |
3.4. Field sampling strategy
| |
HOT program cruises are conducted at approximately monthly intervals;
the exact timing is dictated by the availability of research vessels.
To date, our field observations have not been severely aliased by
month, season or year, except perhaps for a slight under representation of data collected during
April and slight over representation in
October (Karl and Lukas, 1996). From HOT-1 (October 1988) to HOT-65
(August 1995), with the exception of HOT-42 and HOT-43 (November and
December 1992), each cruise was 5 days in duration. Beginning with
HOT-66 (September 1995) the standard HOT cruise was reduced to 4
days in order to accommodate additional mooring-based field
programs within a fixed per annum allocation of ship days.
From HOT-1 (October 1988) to HOT-32 (December 1991), underway
expendable bathythermograph (XBT; Sippican T-7 probes) surveys were
conducted at 13 km spacing on the outbound transect from Station Kahe
to Station ALOHA. These surveys were later discontinued because the
space-time correlation of the energetic, internal semi-diumal tides
made it difficult to interpret these data. From February 1995 until December
1997 we added an instrumented, 1.5 m Endeco towfish package (Sea- Bird CTD,
optical plankton counter, fluorometer) to our sampling program (Tupas et al.
1997). Upper water column currents are measured both underway and on station
using a hull-mounted Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP), when available
(Firing, 1996).
Underway near-surface measurement of a variety of physical, chemical
and biological properties were made possible by sampling seawater through
a pumped intake system positioned in the hull of the R/V Moana Wave. In
May 1995, a thermosalinograph was installed in line to the ship's seawater
intake system. In July 1996, the existing system was replaced with a
noncontaminating PVC/stainless steel system. A flow-through fluorometer
was installed in 1996. The R/V Ka'imikai-o-Kanaloa is outfitted with a
similar seawater intake system to which the existing instruments were
installed when R/V Moana Wave was retired. The R/V Kilo Moana
also has a similar system.
The majority of our sampling effort, approximately 60-72 h per standard
HOT cruise, is spent at Station ALOHA. High vertical resolution environmental
data are collected with a Sea-Bird CTD having external temperature (T),
conductivity (C), dissolved oxygen (DO) and fluorescence (F) sensors and an
internal pressure (P) sensor. A Sea-Bird 24-place carousel and an aluminum
rosette that is capable of supporting 24 12-L PVC bottles are used to obtain
water samples from desired depths. The CTD and rosette are deployed on a
3-conductor cable allowing for real-time display of data and for tripping the
bottles at specific depths of interest. The CTD system takes 24 samples s-1
and the raw data are stored both on the computer and, for redundancy, on
VHS-format video tapes.
In February 2006, before cruise 178, we replaced our 24 aging 12-L PVC
rosette bottles with new 12-L bottles fabricated at the University of Hawaii
Engineering Support Facility, using plans and specifications from John
Bullister (PMEL).
Up until HOT-96 (August 1998), we routinely conducted a dedicated hydrocast
to collect "clean" water samples for biological rate measurements, using General
Oceanics Go-Flo bottles, Kevlar line, a metal-free sheave, Teflon messengers and a
stainless steel bottom weight. During HOT-97 through HOT-118, due to the frequency
of mis-trips & the inability to know the exact depth from which samples were
collected, replicate samples were taken from the CTD rosette and the Go-Flo bottles.
Comparisons with the Go-Flo collected samples showed there was no statistical
difference in rates of 14C-primary production derived from samples collected using
the Go-Flo bottles or the CTD rosette. As a result, beginning with HOT-119 (October
2000), we have collected samples for biological rate measurements only from the
rosette.
A free-drifting sediment trap array, identical in design to the VERTEX
particle interceptor trap (PIT) array (Knauer et al., 1979), is deployed at Station
ALOHA for an approximately 60 hour period to collect sinking particles for chemical
and microbiological analyses.
Sampling at Station ALOHA typically begins with sediment trap
deployment followed by a deep (>4700 m) CTD cast and a "burst series"
of at least 13 consecutive 1000m casts, on 3-hr intervals, to span the
local inertial period (~31 hr) and three semidiurnal tidal cycles. The
repeated CTD casts enable us to calculate an average density profile
from which variability on tidal and near-inertial time scales has been
removed. These average density profiles are useful for the comparison
of dynamic height and for the comparison of the depth distribution of
chemical parameters from different casts and at monthly intervals. For
example, by fitting the distribution of inorganic nutrients to this
average density structure, the depth of the nutricline can be defined
each month, independent from the short time scale changes in the
density structure of the upper water column (Dore and Karl, 1996).
This sampling strategy is designed to assess variability on time scales
of a few hours to a few years. Very high frequency variability (<6 hr) and
variability on time scales of between 3-60 days are not adequately sampled
with our ship-based operations.
Water samples for a variety of chemical and biological measurements are
routinely collected from the surface to within 10 m of the seafloor. To
the extent possible, we collect samples for complementary
biogeochemical measurements from the same or from contiguous casts to
minimize aliasing caused by time-dependent changes in the density
field. This approach is especially important for samples collected in the upper
350 m of the water column. Furthermore, we attempt to sample from
common depths and specific density horizons each month to facilitate
comparisons between cruises. Water samples for salinity determinations
are collected from every water bottle to identify sampling errors.
Approximately 20% of the water samples are collected and analyzed in
duplicate or triplicate to assess and track our precision in
sample analyses.
| |
3.5. Core measurements, experiments
and protocols
| |
The suite of core measurements provides a database to
validate and improve existing biogeochemical models. Our list of core
measurements has evolved since the inception of the HOT program in 1988,
and now includes both continuous and discrete physical, biological and
chemical ship-based measurements, optical, in situ biological rate
experiments, and observations and sample collections from bottom-moored
instruments and buoys. Continuity in the measurement parameters and their
quality, rather than continuity in the methods employed, is of greatest
interest. Detailed analytical methods are expected to change over time
through technical improvements. In addition to the core data, specialized
measurements and process-oriented experiments have also been conducted at
Station ALOHA.
|
|